Nikon D5100 18-55mm VR Kit review
Takes beautiful photos and videos but at this price it needs more accessible controls. We'd stick to the cheaper D3100.
Review Date: 22 Apr 2011
Price when reviewed: £780
Reviewed By: Ben Pitt
Nikon's latest mid-price consumer SLR is pitched to go head-to-head with the Canon EOS 600D The two cameras are uncannily similar, with very little to separate their dimensions, weights and prices. Both can record 1080p video at various frame rates and both have articulated, high-resolution LCD screens - a major asset particularly for video capture.
The Canon nominally has the edge for detail with its 18-megapixel sensor to the Nikon's 16 megapixels. However, the Nikon compensates digitally for lens distortions and chromatic aberrations; the latter can make a big difference to sharpness towards the corners of frames.
The Nikon's 11 autofocus points are two more than Canon offers, and it's a tad faster in continuous mode at 4fps to the Canon's 3.7fps. That advantage only lasted for 13 frames, though, after which it slowed to 1.9fps. The Canon was a little quicker to fire off shots in its Single drive mode, too. However, the Nikon has a dedicated autofocus-assist lamp, so it's quicker to focus in low light when the flash isn't raised. So far, it all adds up to a big fat draw.
In most other respects they're both pretty similar to their entry-level siblings, the Canon EOS 1100D and Nikon D3100. There are 18-55mm stabilised kit lenses all round, along with similarly sized optical viewfinders, solitary command dials and other controls that mostly rely on the LCD screen to relay settings back to the user.
The D5100 is shorter than its predecessor, the D5000, partly because the screen is hinged at the side rather than the bottom. That makes more sense, as it can be flipped out to the side for self-portraits or when the camera is flush against a wall. It also means that the strip of buttons that appeared down the left side of the D5000's screen have been scattered to other parts of the camera.
Find a review
- Lytro Illum light-field digital camera announced
- Eyefi Cloud uploads your photos as you snap them
- Canon EOS 100D White announced, complete with matching white kit lens
- Pentax 645Z medium format DSLR revealed with 51.4-megapixel sensor
- Samsung invite hints at Galaxy S5 Zoom announcement, Galaxy K name change