ViewSonic VEB620 review

Unfortunately, the more we used the eReader, the more irritating things we found about it. For starters, tables of contents in our test book weren't selectable and clickable. For example, reading Jules Verne's The Mysterious Island, we couldn't select which chapter we wanted from the contents, although this feature worked on our Sony PRS-505 (which is, sadly, no longer available).

There also seemed to be some bugs with displaying pages. When we first opened The Mysterious Island, the first half of the first page was missing. However, using the zoom button to cycle through the available font sizes we managed to get it back, whereby every page worked correctly.

The one area we couldn't fix was with PDF files. Reading Stephen E. Ambrose's Band of Brothers, we found that the text wouldn't fit on screen unless we zoomed so far out that the text was too small to read. Instead the VEB620 gave us the option to scroll round each page, which makes reading a book too frustrating. On the Sony PRS-505 the same book simply has the text fitted to the screen with only a couple of minor layout problems at the start of chapters where large drop-caps are used. It's quite a major problem if you buy a lot of books, as many of them are simply PDF transcripts of the original printing documents, rather than specially-created documents for eReaders.

One final minor problem is that the screen isn't always completely updated. For example, after coming out of sleep mode you can still clearly see the words, "Slide and release the power button to wake" at the bottom of the display.

With its slightly annoying menu system, inability to use links embedded in documents and poor handling of PDF books it's hard to recommend the VEB620. Recommending something becomes a little tricky, because the best eBook reader was the Sony PRS-505, which had a metal case. After withdrawing it, Sony replaced it with the plastic-cased Sony Reader Pocket Edition PRS-300. This can be bought for around £149.

If you don't mind getting locked into Amazon's store, the Amazon Kindle 2 costs a similar amount and works well.