Hitachi Deskstar 7K1000.C 1TB review

Gallery

Verdict:

The Deskstar may be cheap, but its inconsistent performance and short warranty means it's poor value.

Review Date: 9 Jul 2010

Price when reviewed: £45

Buy it now for: £49
(see more store prices)

Supplier: http://www.aria.co.uk

Reviewed By: Alan Lu

Our Rating 2 stars out of 5

Review
Specs

The Hitachi Deskstar 7K1000.C is one of the cheapest 1TB internal hard disks we've seen. It costs just 5p per gigabyte thanks to its low price of just £45. Previous Deskstars we've seen have done quite well in our file transfer benchmarks and we had no reason to suspect that the 7K1000.C would be any different. It has a high spindle speed of 7,200rpm, 32MB of cache and uses two 500GB platters, but the results of our benchmarks show that one can't gauge hard disk performance from specifications alone.

We were surprised and disappointed by the Deskstar's inconsistent results in our file transfer tests. It's one of the slowest disks we've seen in a while at writing files. Large files were written at 75.7MB/s, while small files were written at 46MB/s – far behind the competition. Its performance reading files was much better. Large files were read at 103MB/s which is in line what we'd expect, while small files were read very quickly at 104.4MB/s – a chart topping score.

This quick file reading performance was noticeable in our Crysis test, where we timed how long it took the Deskstar to load a large game level. It took 36 seconds which is among the quickest times we've seen for an internal hard disk.

The Deskstar may be cheap, but it is only covered by a one year warranty, which is short compared to the two, three or even five year warranties available for competing disks. Even if you can live with this and the slow write speeds, there are better value disks available. Samsung's SpinPoint F3 1TB costs only £2 more, but its performance is in a different league.

Prev Next

Get more reviews, tutorials and in-depth advice, every month with Computer Shopper.
Click here to try 3 issues for £1

Best Prices

Price comparison powered by

Prices, delivery and availability at 5 retailers		Go
	£49	Go
	£50	Go
	£61	Go
	£70	Go

< Previous Reviews : Internal hard drives Next >

Sponsored Links

User comments

Incorrect Review

One of the main reasons you marked down this hard drive was due to the "one year warranty" but thats completely wrong - the warranty is actually three years on this drive which is at least a good as the competition. The slow transfer speeds criticism seems fair enough, but given that you state in the verdict "short warranty means it's poor value" as one of the main criticisms it would lead me to believe that there was either inadequate research performed in writing this review, or that it is heavily biased. To me this error sort of undermines the whole review (How can we be sure the drive was even setup and tested correctly?)

By Reviewer83 on 11 Oct 2010