Canon PIXMA MG8150 review

The MG8150 produces good prints and great scans, but it's very expensive to buy and run.

16 Dec 2010
Our Rating 
2/5
Price when reviewed 
220
inc VAT

Specifications

12.5ipm print speed, USB, PictBridge, IrDA, 10/100 Ethernet, 802.11 b/g/n wireless, 470x392x199mm

Canon's PIXMA MG8150 is positively hulking. Fortunately it disguises its heft to some extent with a stylish black finish. Although it costs a lot, there's little in its specifications to justify the price. The two main features are a largish 8.8cm screen and the ability to scan film negatives. When doing so its scanner supports up to 4,800x9,600dpi, but on reflective originals the maximum resolution is limited to 4,800x4,800dpi.

Canon PIXMA MG8150

Canon's install program is offers the choice of an XPS driver, supported in Windows Vista or later. In general, XPS should reduce the spooling time on some print jobs, but its chief advantage is an increase in the bit-depth used for each colour channel. This increases the theoretical range of colours (the gamut) that it's possible to send to a printer allowing for a greater number of more subtly different shades, but there's no guarantee that a printer will be able to reproduce them faithfully.

The six-colour print engine in the MG8150 is identical to the one in Canon's cheaper MG6150, which is no bad thing. As you might expect, it matched its times almost exactly across our suite of print tests and delivered indistinguishable results. There's more between the two when it comes to scanning, with the MG8150 significantly quicker on our 150dpi, 300dpi and 600dpi tests. Oddly, it was slightly slower on the 1,200dpi photo scan, but still the second fastest of the group.

We like Canon's scan interface which lets you choose different modes depending how experienced you are at scanning. By default it will only capture a single image per session, returning you to the application into which you're scanning, but there's an option to leave it open when capturing multiple images. There's also an option to play a music file while scanning which, out of curiosity, we enabled. The default MIDI file is awful, but substituting the Girl from Ipanema raised a smile.

Although our tests suggest there's no straightforward link between a printer's specifications and the quality of its results, the MG8150's highly-specified scanner did capture excellent-quality images. While we've seen several MFP scanners which have sharp enough focus to reveal tiny surface scratches on our test photo, the MG8150's uncovered even smaller imperfections. Very light and very dark details were captured, too.

Canon PIXMA MG8150

Canon calls the controls on the PIXMA MG8150 the Intelligent Touch System. In theory it reduces clutter and makes using the device simple by only lighting up those actions that are relevant to the current menu. Although it's quick to respond and it looks great until mottled by fingerprints, we're fairly sure that a touchscreen is more intuitive still. It's also odd that the screen and primary controls are on the scanner lid. Although people rarely need to scan large objects, the controls could prove unreachable if the lid won't fully close.

A bigger disappointment considering the high purchase price is the high print costs. At 10p per page, it's one of the most expensive inkjet printers around at the moment. Although, this is an excellent multifunction device – and one of few that can capture and archive 35mm film – it's not worth the premium over the Epson PX720WD.

Basic Specifications

Rating **
Maximum native print resolution 9,600x2,400dpi
Max optical resolution 4,800x9,600dpi
Output bit depth 48-bit

Quoted Speeds

Quoted speed, mono A4 12.5ipm
Quoted speed, colour A4 9.3ipm

Tested Print Speeds

Time for two 10x8in photos 1.0 3m 54s
Time for six 6x4in photos 1.0 4m 52s

Physical and Environmental

Standard printer interfaces USB, PictBridge, IrDA, 10/100 Ethernet, 802.11 b/g/n wireless
Optional printer interfaces Bluetooth
Size 470x392x199mm
Weight 10.7kg
Noise (in normal use) 46dB(A)

Paper Handling

Maximum paper size A4/legal
Maximum paper weight 300gsm
Standard paper inputs 2
Standard paper input capacity 300
Maximum paper inputs 2
Maximum paper input capacity 300
Duplex (code, cost if option) Yes

General

Printer technology thermal inkjet
Supported operating systems Windows XP/Vista/Vista-64/7/7-64, Mac OS X 10.4.11+
Other inkjet features 8.8cm colour screen, automatic print head alignment, replaceable print head
Other inkjet options none

Buying Information

Price £220
Consumable parts and prices £10
Price per colour A4 page 7.1p
Quoted life of supplied black cartridge 328 pigment black (ISO/IEC 24712)
Quoted life of supplied colour cartridge(s) 2,185 dye black, 1,515 grey pages (estimate), 462 cyan, 437 magenta, 450 yellow pages (ISO/IEC 24712)
Quoted life of supplied photo cartridge(s) N/A
Warranty one-year RTB
Supplier http://www.morecomputers.com
Details www.canon.co.uk

Print Quality

Number of ink colours 6
Number of ink cartridges 6
Maximum number of ink colours 6
Maximum number of cartridges 6
Quoted photo durability 30 years
Quoted photo durability source Canon

Tested Scan Speeds

Full scan area preview 6s
A4 document at 150dpi 6s
A4 document at 300dpi 8s
6x4in photo at 600dpi 13s
6x4in photo at 1200dpi 55s

Tested Copy Speeds

Time for single A4 mono copy 1.0 13s
Time for single A4 colour copy 1.0 22s
Time for 10 A4 copies using feeder 2.0 N/A

Photo Features

PictBridge support Yes
Borderless printing A4
Direct (PC-less) printing Yes
Supported memory cards USB flash, CF, SD, SDHC, MMC, Memory Stick Pro, MicroDrive
CD printing Yes

Copy Features

Maximum number of copies 99

Fax Features

Max mono fax resolution N/A
Fax memory (maximum mono pages) N/A